Digital or Analog? How to Pick a Retro Watch in 2026

Both are period correct. The 80s ran the LCD digital watch and the analog dial alongside each other for the whole decade and neither killed the other. But they pull an outfit in opposite directions, and the price gap in our range is wide enough that the decision deserves two minutes.

What each one signals

Digital. A rectangular LCD reads as technical and faintly playful. It is the more obviously 80s of the two, because the digital watch was genuinely new then and everybody knew it. When the Casio F-91W arrived in 1989 it cost almost nothing, kept excellent time, and went on to become one of the best selling watches ever made, which is a strange fate for a piece of plastic. Digital sits naturally with sportswear, a bomber, sneakers. It looks out of place with anything formal, and that is fine as long as you know it going in.

Analog. A round dial with hands reads as ordinary, in the best sense of the word. It works with everything including a shirt cuff, and it does not pin you to a decade. Less of a statement, more of a watch.

If you want the piece noticed, digital. If you want a watch you never think about again, analog.

Case size, which matters more than style

Case diameter decides whether a watch looks right on you, and almost nobody checks it before buying.

Measure your wrist with a tape or a strip of paper. Roughly: under 17cm suits a case around 36 to 40mm. Over 18cm can carry 42mm and up. A 44mm case on a narrow wrist overhangs the bone on both sides and looks like you are wearing someone else's watch, because visually you are.

Digital complicates this slightly, since a rectangular case measures differently from a round one and usually wears smaller than the number implies. On a small wrist, digital is the safer bet.

The strap

The strap changes the watch more than people expect, and it is the cheapest thing to get wrong.

Metal bracelet. Dressier, heavier, and the most period correct option on a digital watch. Needs sizing to your wrist by removing links, which is five minutes with a pin tool or two minutes with a jeweller.

Leather or faux leather. Warmer, quieter, better with shirts and jackets. Wears out faster and hates water.

Resin or silicone. Light, waterproof, sporty. The right answer for a digital watch you want to stop thinking about.

Our range, by price

$19.99 to $29.99. The entry tier, mostly analog. The Retro Design Men's Watch and Blue Ray Analog are $19.99. Digital here means the Black Digital Watch 1982 at $22.99, its silver twin, and the Digital Futuristic Watch 1989 at $23.99. At this price a watch is an accessory you can own three of without a conversation at home.

$38 to $50. Where a watch starts to feel like an object on the wrist. The Military Watch 1986 at $38.90, the Digitron Watch 1982 and Chromaflux Watch 1986 at $39.99, the Futuristic Waterproof Watch 1986 at $44.99, and the Retro Leather Watch 1983 at $49.99. The 1986 waterproof is the one people come back for.

$75 and up. The TimeScape Navigator Watch 1984 at $75.99 and the Retro Futurism Watch 1989 at $199. Buy at this level because you want that specific watch, not as a general upgrade.

Questions we get

Is water resistant the same as waterproof? No, and the difference has drowned a lot of watches. Water resistant usually means splashes and rain. Swimming needs a proper rating, and the models with waterproof in the name are the ones built for it. Read the listing rather than hoping.

Can I wear a digital watch with a shirt? With a casual shirt, yes. Under a formal cuff it looks like you got dressed in a hurry, which may of course be accurate.

Do they come with batteries? Yes, and a quartz movement will typically run a year or two before it needs a new one. Any watch shop replaces them in a few minutes for very little.

Can I swap the strap myself? On most of them, yes. A standard spring bar strap comes off with a cheap tool and takes about five minutes, which is the single cheapest way to make a $23 watch look like a different watch. Check the lug width on the listing before buying a replacement strap.

Which is better for a gift? Digital in the $22 to $25 range. No sizing risk, low commitment, and instantly recognisable as retro. Our gift guide covers the rest.

The honest recommendation

If this is your first retro watch, take a digital one at $22 to $25. It is the more distinctive of the two looks, the small case suits most wrists, and it is cheap enough that a mistake costs nothing. Wear it constantly and you have learned to spend more next time. Leave it in a drawer and you learned that for $23 rather than $199, which is the best value in this entire article.

Related reading: the beauty of analog watches in a digital world · the vintage watch style guide

Explore the collections: Watches · 80s Men's Fashion